Monthly Archive for June, 2009

30 June 2009: Support for Embassy grows

Yesterday, our first day of being open for business as an Embassy was busy: visitors, media, phone calls and emails. We are finding that the maps of the whole area attract attention as visitors begin to comprehend the scale of what is being done. There were lots of cups of tea, chats around the fireside, scones and a choice of jams and local honey. Diane distinguished herself for rejecting a scone with vegemite - call yourself Australian!

A late morning visit from the Department of Environment and Heritage: Allan Holmes (Chief Executive, DEH), Russell Seaman (Environmental Manager, Coorong, Lower Lakes and Murray Mouth, DEH), Louise, Amanda Pritchard, a photographer and Kate (an international student), popped into the Fresh Water Embassy. They were on a trip to the Finniss River and Currency Creek and then across the barrages.

The Embassy staff was quick to offer our legendary hospitality with hot tea and scones and settled in for a chat around the campfire.  It was a hard-hitting exchange that ranged over our concerns with the lack of consultation, the nature of the science driving policy decisions and the rationale for the weirs (“Regulators”). Allan Holmes wanted to have further conversations.  “Why now?” asked Henry Jones. “It’s too late. The damage is being done in front of our eyes. We needed to have these kinds of conversations years ago.”

Anne Hartnett, Chair of the RLCAG, explained, “Our group started because we weren’t being consulted and we are still are not been consulted. We are being talked at and talked down to.” “At meetings,” Gloria Jones said, “We haven’t been able to speak about weirs. We’ve been talked to, not listened to. We’re invited to meetings and not allowed to put our point. We can only talk to what they presented”

The meeting at Clayton, chaired by Dean Brown, came in for a considerable amount of criticism. “People here are polite,” said Diane Bell. “But don’t mistake that for agreement. They are angry. They have been disrespected and told they wouldn’t understand.” At this point the exchange heated up a little and Allan tried to appease us with promise of further open meetings. “With access to all materials,” Diane insisted. “And none of this claiming documents are ‘confidential’ and have to be kept secret.”

Anne echoed what we have all been saying about the science on which these decisions are based. “It is new. They are still learning. This ASS science is speculative and we are not being given access to the relevant materials. The ‘experts’ are coming here now from other universities to do experiments.” “We are not convinced by the science,” Henry Jones stated. “When we went to school science was objective,” said Anne to Henry Jones, “but now it is being taken over by politics and industry. We need to have conversations at the top level about how to balance the needs of the environment with that of irrigators. ”

“I want you to know that these weirs at Clayton Bay, on the Finniss River and Currency Creek are trashing a spiritually important spot and that building these weirs is overkill,” Anne explained. “Salt will be trapped on Goolwa side of the barrage in the new weir pool,’ said Henry Jones. “And it will be worse than ASS. This pool could not be considered an ecological refuge. There will be major fish kills by February/March if the drought continues.

“We are a non-violent group,” Henry emphasised. ”And this is a peaceful vigil.” “But this does not mean we agree with what is happening,” said Diane. “And what is happening with the Pomanda weir?” Allan Holmes did not want to talk about Pomanda. ”And that is one of the problems with your approach,” said Diane. “You have no over-all plan and the Long Term, 10 million planning exercise that is currently underway is being spun. When you drill down on the website for the evidence to support your assertions, you find Media Releases, not science.” Allan Holmes agreed about the political spin and admitted the “experts” were not necessarily particularly good at communicating. “But we will do better,” he insisted and said that he and Russell Seaman would get the material we wanted together and meet with us again.

Array

Array

Array


Cynthia Jones says it was the most exciting day of her life.

The flag raising was a bit of a test of ingenuity today. (Don’t forget to pass the cursor over the image to read the caption and click on the image to increase size.)

Array

The road on Kumarangk (Hindmarsh Island) has reached the foreshore and gone straight over the reeds and rushes. What happens when they start to break down?

Array

Where is the Minister? We had heard that Minister Jay Weatherill was going to visit the Milang school children who have been working on the “Save the Turtles” project and they were preparing for his arrival at 3.00pm.  But the DEH team knew he was in Adelaide. So why is the Minister in Adelaide when he is supposed to be in Milang? Why could he not visit with his team? Our invitation to visit is an open one. Give us a call and we will put on the kettle.

Rain: Our bioremediation plot is enjoying the rain. Today, it is sheeting down. The Finniss River has surface a sheet of freshwater and when we get a break in the rain, we’ll start monitoring. Is the sulfuric acid being mobilised or is it being diluted? We have asked to see the EPA monitoing results but are yet to see their data.

Greetings: Climate Emergency Action Network CLEAN SA and Friends of the Earth Adelaide emailed us to say: “Well done to all !! - will join the RLCAG so can keep in touch - hope to be down there again in the next fortnight - sending diplomatic greetings and support from the Climate Emergency Action Network CLEAN SA and Friends of the Earth Adelaide, All the best, Jenny.

Serve the People website carried the story of the launch with some stunning photographs.

Commentary on Adelaide Now: “The commencement of the building of the Clayton weir follows the building of the weir to cut off Lake Albert. The use of the Lower Lakes for water supply is be bypassed by privatised pipelines and continues this government’s bastardisation of the Lower Lakes to appease the Eastern States.” Read on …

And more photographs of the launch

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

June 28: Fresh Water Embassy Launch

What a day! The Embassy staff was up and at it by 8.00 a.m. Embassy Head Quarters was bedecked with banners; under the green turtle umbrella, the tube-worm encrusted turtles were dramatic evidence of the high salinity levels of the Lakes; the flag poles were secured, fires set, display boards finalised and, by 8.30am, the first visitors had arrived - one by boat with the message that we had support in Goolwa. The Ngarrindjeri arrived by bus and car: aunties, uncles, grandparents and grannies (grandchildren). The crowd gathered at the Look Out on the cliff at Clayton Bay. They came from around the lake, from Meningie and Narrung, from up river from Mannum, from Adelaide, Milang, Langhorne Creek, Strathalbyn, the Adelaide Hills and Germany. The wind came up. No rain, just a sign we should start.

Array

Array

Array


Array

Array

Ngarrindjeri welcome: We counted 250 people on a windy cliff as Ngarrindjeri elder Major Sumner, in full ceremonial mode, clicked the boomerangs, called to the ancestors of the Ngarrindjeri and the settler population to come down and to join us. Elder Tom Trevorrow spoke of our need to stand together and the Ngarrindjeri opposition to the construction of more weirs. The ti-tree smokey fire enveloped the crowd and then, at the invitation of Tom Trevorrow, we walked through the healing smoke.

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Flag raising: Next we raised the flags: the Ngarrindjeri flag for the traditional owners of the land; the Australian flag to emphasise that we were at the end of Australia’s River; and the Lower River Murray flag. Framed between the Ngarrindjeri flag and Australian flag, the approach road on Kumarangk (Hindmarsh Island) was a scar on the landscape.

Array

Array

Array

Why an Embassy?: Diane Bell invited the crowd to help build the Embassy.  “It’s a Community project,” she said. “We needed to feel we could do something together. The pain, sorrow, anguish and loss of those who live here, care for and love this country is palpable. We see the changes on a daily basis. We see the consequences of decades of mismanagement and over-allocation. We are asked to watch and listen as the bulldozers edge forward on Kumarangk (Hindmarsh Island) and next week begin to dump rocks and clay into this stretch of water.  Then the pumps will start. We need to be able to say this is not OK. We are watching. This is not being done in our name. We need you to understand what is happening.” Continue reading the welcoming speech…welcome-june-28

Array

Building an Embassy: The Embassy staff, who had worked on the “Sea of Statements” set out the corflutes along the cliff edge and extended an invitation to those present to write their own messages.

Array

Array


Array

Array

Array

Establishing diplomatic relations with others: The Fresh Water Embassy was acknowledged and diplomatic relations were sought and accepted: Mayor Kym McHugh, Alexandrina Council, David Winderlich, Democrat, MLC, Mark Parnell, Australian Greens, MLC, Trevor Hammond for Adrian Pederick, MP. Peter Smith brought greetings from the Murray-Darling Basin Association and Peter Laffin from the Salt Water Friends of St Vincent’s Gulf.

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

The Ambassador arrives: Ngori (the pelican) had been sighted earlier in the day in Clayton Bay and over the water, but as the speeches were being made, Ngori swooped low over the assembled group, flew through the smoke and headed off to visit the fresh water of the tributaries.

Array

Tea and scones at HQ: The crowd walked down the hill and were greeted by Gloria and Henry Jones’ hospitality. At HQ people were able to explore the information of the display boards, learn more of the turtle project run by the school children, heard from Keith Walker, fresh water ecologist, and Carole Richardson, Bioremediation Project Officer. Then we planted native grasses of the local region on the foreshore. This will be part of the educational function of the Embassy and we will be monitoring the growth.

More photos posted June 30.

WE HAVE AN EMBASSY!

27 June 2009: Trial Run

Last day for setting up. The banners and flag poles arrived with JB.  More corflutes with JT. Conduit with MC. Hot potato wedges with SR. Rope and all manner of implements with HJ. Drill with RH. Hammer with DB. Literature and rocks with JY. Plants with CR. It was sunny as we emptied the shed and began laying out the display boards and literature. We hauled the flags, poles and corflute statements to the Look Out and in the brilliant sun set up the flag poles and flew the flags.

Array

Array

Array

Array

Lots of phone calls back and forth. Fingers crossed that all is in place.

Tomorrow is the launch. See you there

26 June 2009: Q&A at the Embassy

Today visitors came by with questions and congratulations on the Jill Hudson Award.

Array

Array

Array


(Don’t forget to pass the cursor over the photo to read the caption.)

The map of the Lower Lakes on loan from Carole Richardson is a winner. Even people who live in Clayton are uncertain about the location and structure of the weir. Rob Hylton not only did yeoman service with the display boards but fielded questions about the “big picture”.

Array

Here is the wisdom of our “Backwater Boatman”.

“Just open the barrages, let the sea water in- it’s that easy!!!!”

But is it that easy?

If the tidal flow in and out of the Murray Mouth could keep the mouth open, then we would not need to spend the $10 million each year on dredging that we do now.

If the tidal flow from the Lake could keep the mouth open, then it stands to reason that the current tidal flow from the Coorong would keep it open at least a bit.

The reality is that the vast quantity of sand drifting north along the great Southern Ocean beach blocks the mouth unless there is a constant flow of water out through the mouth. Tidal flow is a stop start affair that the ocean sand can soon over power. Sand is brought into the mouth with the incoming tide. As the tide flow slows before the turn of tide, this sand begins to settle and reduces the size of the mouth.This inturn reduces the ability of the out flowing tide to clear the sand. More sand settles with each in coming tide, till eventually the mouth is closed.

In the past, when the river flows reduced, the mouth was slowly closed off in this way. If the Murray River ceased to flow, the mouth would block. (Though this seems to have been a vary rare occurrence prior to man made water extraction.) This sand blockage prevented sea water entering the lakes and Coorong just as effectively as out flowing fresh water had done. Fresh water still entered the lakes from the south east inter dune wetlands via the Coorong.

The rivers of the eastern Mt Lofty Ranges also fed fresh water into the lakes: Currency Creek, Finniss River, Angus River and the Marne River. Salinity still increased due to ground water incursions and evaporation but this salinity, this brackishness, was no where near the salt content of the Sea.

It will not be a case of ‘let in the sea’ by opening the barrages. It will require constant dredging at the mouth on a greater scale than is done today to avoid a steady increase in salinity to hyper saline levels as has been experienced by the Coorong Southern Lagoon.

A short lived flush of life will exploit the transition then slowly life, both fresh water and sea water, will be choked on salt. Salt laden winds will damage vineyards. Corporate shareholders will sell up or simply cut their loses and move to where the tax incentives and the water are.

To bring in sea water will be a serious dose of salts for both the environment and the taxpayer.

The water levels we see now are below sea level. This saline water cannot be let out of the lake if we wanted to. The more saline this water becomes and the more regulators that stop fresh water entering the Lake Alexandrina, the less likely it is that the lakes will recover their fresh water habitats.

Salt marshes and saline swamps are intriguing environments but are they what South Australia needs in place of its largest freshwater reservoir!

The Embassy was a welcome stopover for little ones on their lunch break.

Array

Bruce Allnutt solved the problem of sandbags needed to hold down the flag poles. Check it out on Sunday.

Array

As the work crew knocked off for the week, a soft rain set in, the house boat is still there and the road has reached the shore line.

Array

Q. Will you be there to see this incredibly beautiful stretch of water on Sunday before the fresh waters of the tributaries is cut off from Lake Alexandrina?=

Array

Array

FAQ: “A cuppa?”

A: “Yes please.”

The Fresh Water Embassy needs more tea bags.

25 June 2009

Today we continued setting up the Fresh Water Embassy - so much sweeping, sorting and stacking - but we now have the capacity to prepare basic meals: microwave, jug, cords. With the help of Peter Bullock, we have hooks and message boards and corflutes on which people can write messages on Sunday at the launch. The display boards have minds of their own, not that we can complain, they are free: the remnants of previous campaigns.

According to the work SA Water schedule we have, the road on Hindmarsh Island should have been completed today. It wasn’t. But the workers now a have a base camp of their own. See the reflections of the temporary toilets in the still water. The house boat is yet to be moved.

Array

Jill Hudson Environmental Award goes to …

“The tragedy of the River Murray is a legacy of the neglect of many generations,” reads this morning’s Adelaide Advertiser (26/06/09).

Last night  the River, Lakes and Coorong Action Group Inc won the Jill Hudson Award for Environmental Protection for their work in trying to undo this tragic legacy. They shared the award with Peter Laffin.

The Conservation Council of SA chose the RLCAG  because of the remarkable contribution they have made to saving the Murray and the significant obstacles they have had to overcome.

In accepting the award from the Minister Jay Weatherill, Professor Diane Bell described the moment as “bitter-sweet” and invited the Minister to the launch of the Fresh Water Embassy on Sunday June 28 at 10.30am. She said, “We think it is time you stood on the cliff at Clayton Bay with us, looked over to Kumarangk (Hindmarsh Island) and saw the dynamic movement of water down the tributaries and into Lake Alexandrina before that life giving water in cut off by ‘Regulators’ (weirs).” pr-rlcag-jill-hudson-award-250609

24 June 2009: HQ takes shape

A crystal clear morning at Clayton Bay and the Fresh Water Embassy staff were hard at work getting ready for Sunday. Henry Jones was at Head Quarters (HQ) early and within the hour had rigged up a tarp to shelter us from the wind and weather. Marian Thompson began emptying out the shed, sweeping, sorting and rearranging.

Array

Array


Array

Array

Diane Bell was up at Embassy Look Out having a chat on ABC 891 about the plans for Sunday and the rationale for the Embassy. Ngarrindjeri Elder, Tom Trevorrow joined the conversation and explained the grief the Ngarrindjeri who were being forced to endure damage and interference with their sacred places. media-release-ngarrindjeri-18-june-09. From the Embassy Look Out, the road works on the island that are edging forward are clearly visible and the throb of the engines filled the air.

Array

By lunch time Diane and Marian had the shed clean - with some help from Dave - had taken visitors to our Look Out and organised a fridge and a hot plate for Diane’s home-made soup. Anne Harnett arrived with seven bags of firewood (one a day for the first week), tent pegs and bolts; Suzy Rex delivered the plastic storage boxes, plates, tea, coffee, jars and tasteful basket boxes; Rob Hylton helped us solve the banner-hanging problem and set about installing new display boards. Janette and Bruce Brooks from Finniss and Bev and Alex Stone from Point Sturt joined in the banner extravaganza. Peter Bullock and Suzy brought the urn. Anne delivered another table. After a few mis-starts we got the display boards to stand up. Marie-Claire Levi photographed the action and a good thing too because Diane’s camera decided it was time to pack it in. Who else? The police popped in to tell us about their new arrangements and to give us contact numbers. Meg came by as we were packing up, as did Jane who was walking her two dogs along the foreshore. Marie-Claire produced a fabulous cake and we settled into watch the sun set and enjoy the food. The trucks were still working on the road.

Array

Array

Array

Array


Array

Array

Array

Array


Array

Array

Array

22 June 2009: Corflutes galore

Continuing the countdown to the June 28 launch of the Fresh Water Embassy: The roomy Milang Shed, a sunny June afternoon, a stack of corflutes left over from a political campaign, marker pens, some double sided tape, an ingenious group of a people and we were ready to begin on our “Sea of Statements” for the Fresh Water Embassy. (Don’t forget to pass the cursor over the photograph to see the captions.)

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Array

Then a last look at the waters between Clayton Bay and Hindmarsh Island. The earth moving equipment is now visible on the Kumarangk (Hindmarsh Island).

Array

Array

Tomorrow, we will start work on our flags.

For details on the Embassy go to

21 June 2009: Fresh Water Embassy First Steps

Count down to June 28 launch of the Fresh Water Embassy

It was a pleasant Sunday afternoon for members of the River, Lakes and Coorong Action Group Inc (RLCAG) to be out and about. The permit for our planned peaceful vigil at Clayton Bay was received from the Alexandrina Council on Friday June 19, so we spent several hours figuring out the logistics of banners, storage, siting for our fires, a bioremediation plot and enjoying a cuppa and poppy-seed cake.

Preparations for the Fresh Water Embassy will be ongoing all week: a workshop on banner and placard making; rosters will be composed; literature printed; firewood collected; and many emails and phone calls.

We will be documenting the progress of the Embassy on Flickr

21 June 2009, Clayton Bay21 June 2009, Clayton Bay21 June 2009, Clayton Bay21 June 2009, Clayton Bay21 June 2009, Clayton Bay21 June 2009, Clayton Bay21 June 2009, Clayton Bay21 June 2009, Clayton Bay21 June 2009, Clayton Bay22 June 2009: Milang Shed Corflutes22 June 2009: Milang Shed Corflutes22 June 2009: Milang Shed Corflutes22 June 2009: Milang Shed Corflutes22 June 2009: Milang Shed Corflutes22 June 2009: Milang Shed Corflutes22 June 2009: Milang Shed Corflutes22 June 2009: Milang Shed Corflutes22 June 2009: Last llook Clayon Bay22 June 2009: Last look Clayton Bay24 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200924 June 200925 June 200925 June 200925 June 2009, Clayton Bay26 June 2009: Clayton Bay26 June 2009: Clayton Bay26 June 2009: Clayton Bay26 June 2009: Clayton Bay26 June 2009: Clayton Bay26 June 2009: Clayton Bay26 June 2009: Clayton Bay26 June 2009: Clayton Bay

Remember to pass the cursor over the photograph so you can read the caption.

For details on the Embassy go to

18 June 2009: Ngarrindjeri pain and loss

In a Media Statement, the Ngarrindjeri speak of their pain and loss that will be a consequence of the construction of Regulators across their sacred waters.

“Through their representative bodies, the Ngarrindjeri Tendi Inc, Ngarrindjeri Heritage Committee Inc, and Ngarrindjeri Native Title Management Committee, the Ngarrindjeri people state that the construction of the regulators at Clayton Bay and across the Finniss River and Currency Creek will result in the damage, disturbance and interference with their lands, waters and sky.

“We will suffer pain and loss as a result of the actions of the State in proceeding with construction of these regulators,” said Tom Trevorrow, Chair of the Ngarrindjeri Heritage Committee Inc. “In January 2009, we said that we did not support a weir at Clayton and that we supported an holistic approach to the problems occurring in the River, Lower Lakes and Coorong due to over allocation of water. That is still our position, but now there are three regulators that will cut up our country and waters.” Continue reading media-release-ngarrindjeri-18-june-09