Monthly Archive for July, 2010

31 July 2010: Save our Gulfs Embassy Launch

Water stories: Take it with a pinch of salt*

But I thought the desalination plant would take the pressure off the River Murray.
But I thought that Lakes Alexandrina and Albert were always salt.
But I thought the rain/currents washed the salt out to sea.
Wrong! Wrong! Wrong!

Thirsty for some common sense on how to live in our land of drought and flooding rains? Wondering what a sustainable Australia might look like?

Join us on Saturday July 31 at 11 am, at 64a Semaphore Rd, Semaphore, when the “Save our Gulfs” campaigners and the “Save the River Murray” campaigners connect their stories with other “water warriors”.

Help us make history as we establish the “Save our Gulfs Embassy”.

River advocate, Professor Diane Bell will bring greetings and support from the Fresh Water Embassy. ‘It is becoming a familiar pattern,’ says Bell. ‘We are told there is solid science to support management and development strategies such as the construction of dams/weirs/bunds/desalination plants, but when we seek independent review of the materials we are denied access to key reports, monitoring is inadequate and the goal posts keep moving.’

‘The River Murray is at Code Catastrophic but it can be saved. Our actions have held off the construction of weir across the River Murray below Wellington and our sustained critique of the construction of so-called regulators has challenged the ‘science’ on which the decision purport to be based.’

‘I see strong parallels with the desalination plant,’ says Bell. ‘It is true that a considerable financial investment has been made in the plant, but what is the Gulf worth? Are we prepared to sacrifice this ecological hot spot? Are we ready to kill the Gulfs with hyper saline discharges and chemical wastes? Or, are we prepared to learn from the mistakes made by other desalination plants?’

It is not too late. There are alternatives.

For the past four years the River, Lakes and Coorong Action Group (inc.) has been commenting, critiquing and correcting the pronouncements of the state and federal government on matters concerning their management strategies for the Murray-Darling River Basin. We have argued that it is over-allocation, not drought that is killing the system. We have advocated for fresh water flows down the River Murray to flush the accumulated salts and nutrients to sea. We have explained that rivers die from the bottom up. A healthy river is a pre-condition to healthy communities and healthy economies.

‘Now it is time to join forces with those working for healthy gulfs,’ says Bell. ‘It is time to show how our those issues are connected. It is time to look at the ‘big picture’ and to take action together.’

* Latin cum grano salis, literally with a grain of salt, figuratively with some doubt

29 July 2010: Meeting with the Minister

Saving our Rivers and Gulfs: Water Actions

Meeting with the Minister for the Environment and Conservation, Minister for the River Murray and Minister for Water, July 28, 2010

Storm water, desalination plants, Environmental Impact Statements, privatisation and community engagement with the Murray-Darling Basin Plan were all on the agenda at the July 28 meeting of local environmental groups with Minister Paul Caica in Adelaide.

‘We were delighted when the Minister visited the Fresh Water Embassy at Clayton Bay on June 17,’ said Professor Diane Bell. ‘We hoped then that we were entering a new phase in bringing our concerns to government and we are further encouraged by this meeting.’

Corrie Vanderhoek of the Save our Gulf Coalition, John Caldecott of the Water Action Coalition and Diane Bell from the Fresh Water Embassy spent an hour in dialogue with the Minister and three of his advisors.

‘The biodiversity of the Gulfs of St Vincent and Spencer Gulf is not widely known, said Corrie Vanderhoek. ‘We were able to present the Minister with briefing documents regarding environmental threats posed by the desalination plant at Port Stanvac.’ For more on the Save our Gulfs campaigns go to portwalkabout.com

“When will South Australia’s minimum entitlement of 1850 Gl be established?” asked John Caldecott who presented a critique of the problems raised by privatisation of water. For more on the work of the Water Action Coalition (WAC) go to http://civictrust.net.au/page19.htm

‘The Minister is setting a cracking pace in advocating for the special needs of South Australians with reference to the Murray-Darling Basin Plan; saving the threatened congolli; planning how his new supra-Department of Environment and Natural Resources will manage its duties and addressing the issues we are raising,’ said Bell.

‘Our concerns were wide ranging, the discussion intense and robust. There are matters on which we agree to disagree,’ said Bell. ‘We are seeking access to reports and we are seeking answers to a number of complex questions. We expect to have an indication within 1-2 weeks of which matters can be addressed quickly and a schedule for dealing with the others.’

6 July 2010: Who speaks for the environment?

As of 1 July 2010, the Lower Lakes and Coorong Recovery became part of the new Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR). The new department has three goals:
* to build sustainable communities;
* to steward our natural resources;
* and to provide public places for community benefit.

What happened to the environment?
1. As of July 1, the Department of Environment and Heritage (DEH) became DENR - http://www.environment.sa.gov.au/

DENR encompasses the old DEH and Natural Resource Management staff and State Flora staff from DWLBC - thus integrating the government’s natural resource management services into a single department.

So who speaks for the environment?
DENR says: “Our business is the sustainability of South Australia. Our challenge is to work with the Government and the community to respond to environmental challenges such as climate change and to find a way of life that is both prosperous and economically and environmentally sustainable.”

So it appears DENR has to balance economic and environmental factors.

Who then advocates for the environment?

DENR says “We collect and provide information and knowledge about the state’s environment. We manage the state’s public land including national parks, marine parks, botanic gardens and the coastline. We also advise on environmental policy.”

To advise is not to advocate or defend or protect. In whose interests is advice offered?

With whom does DENR work? “DENR is part of the Environment and Conservation Portfolio and reports to the Minister for Environment and Conservation. We deliver the Government’s environment policies directly and through partnerships. These are with other government agencies, including the Department of Water, Land and Biodiversity Conservation, the Environment Protection Authority, Zero Waste SA, Natural Resources Management Boards, and Primary Industries and Resources SA, as well as & a wide range of non-government environment organisations, industry bodies and the community.”

“Our work is determined by our obligation to achieve related targets in South Australia’s Strategic Plan to administer legislation dedicated to our Minister and to respond to the needs of South Australians.”
So who speaks for the environment?

2. As of July 1, 2010, a new Department for Water, led by Scott Ashby as Chief Executive, took on some of the work of the old Department of Water, Land, and Biodiversity Conservation, DWLBC. See http://www.waterforgood.sa.gov.au/

DW says, “Water is fundamental to our health, our way of life and our environment. The new Department will ensure that there are always sufficient and sustainable water resources in South Australia for our health, our economy, our environment and our lifestyle.”

Who speaks for the environment?

DW says, “To ensure our water future to 2050 and beyond, we are putting South Australia’s water security plan, Water for Good, into action.

Released in June 2009, Water for Good outlines 94 actions to make sure our water supplies are secure, safe, diverse, reliable and able to sustain a growing population and a growing economy in a changing climate.”

Who speaks for the environment?

14 July 2010: River stories

photos to be uploaded

July 2010: Desal News

phots to be loaded

12 July 2010: Irrigators visit


6 July 2010: Crossing the bridge

photos yet to be posted

1 July 2010: EIS update

Members of the old Departments of Environment and Heritage and the Department of Water, Lands and Biodiversity Conservation met with Diane Bell and Henry Jones in Clayton.

30 June 2010: Meeting with the Senate

Diane Bell and John Caldecott were invited to Canberra to give evidence to the Senate Committee conducting the Inquiry into Water (Crisis Powers and Flood Water Diversion) Bill 2010.

Diane Bell addressed
* the distinction between conceptualising the River as a living system and water as a commodity in terms of how we ‘manage’ the Murray-Darling River system
* the Ngarrindjeri and ecological proposition that ‘all things are connected’
* the opportunity the bill provides to discuss the current water crisis
* her work with the Law Reform Commission in the 1980s
* the need to understand the history of the current crisis before proposing solutions
* the capacity of the Murray-Darling Basin Authority to ‘manage’ the syste,
and asked ‘Does the legislation help?’

John Caldecott spoke to the matter of the need for a Royal Commission
WAC, in its submission is arguing that the Bill does not go far enough.We firmly believe that nothing short of a full public inquiry, with powers of a Royal Commission, can unravel decades of bad policy at all levels, gross mismanagement and ongoing exploitation of the waters of the Murray-Darling Basin that has continued to this very day. A Royal Commission is required to determine the systemic root causes and propose solutions fundamental to a proper long-term corrective action process.

24-7 June 2010: Flood Waters

Photos yet to be loaded - stay tuned

Mt Lyndhurst
Bedourie
Innaminka